Will I lose out if I combine my pensions and ditch my third-party manager?

15 November 2019


I have two substantial pensions with Aviva and Scottish Widows worth in excess of £500,000 each. I cannot put any further money in as I am limited by the lifetime allowance. Both funds are administered through a third-party manager.

Should l combine my pensions and ditch my third-party manager?



The pension lifetime allowance of £1,055,000 is likely to increase with inflation each year. If you exceed it, when you take your pension benefits you will face a tax charge. It is sensible to stop making pension contributions, unless, as a result, it means you will miss out on generous employer contributions.

Each of your pensions is likely to offer a wide range of investment fund options, so you should select options which are suitable for you. It is unlikely that you can cut out investment fund charges, although you should be able to reduce them by investing in the funds managed by Aviva and Scottish Widows or by selecting tracker funds.

There are generally advantages in consolidating different pension pots, including making the administration easier if everything is in the same place. However, as you only have two large pension pots your administration should be relatively easy to manage.

It could be that you can move both of your pensions to a different scheme, which is more flexible or has better investment options or lower charges. 

However, there may be costs involved in transferring your pension and you could lose valuable guarantees, such as guaranteed annuities, which are not usually available on newer-style pensions. You might also miss out on investment gains if you are out of the market while the transfer takes place.

Before deciding whether to transfer your pensions, you should make sure that you fully understand the charges and terms and conditions for both of them. This will give you a better idea whether consolidation is a good idea. However, these are really important decisions and so if you’re not sure what you’re doing you should take independent financial advice.

Patrick Connolly, certified financial planner at Chase de Vere

Do you have a money question for our panel of experts?

At Moneywise, we have a panel of top experts to help with your money and investing questions. If you have a tax issue that’s keeping you awake at night, a question about investing that you’ve always wondered but been too shy to ask, or even need a full money makeover for free, we’d love to hear from you.

If you have been treated unfairly by a firm send the details to Moneywise’s Fight for your Rights and we could take up the fight for you.

Email fightback@moneywise.co.uk

If you have a question about your investments or investing in general, put it to our Investment Doctor.

Email editor@moneywise.co.uk

If you have a question about your personal finances – anything from tax to state pensions, inheritance tax, property sales and more – write to our Ask the experts panel.

Email advice@moneywise.co.uk

Would you like a full money makeover? We will arrange a free one-to-one meeting for you with an FCA-regulated independent financial adviser worth over £2,000.

See Moneywise.co.uk/money-makeover for more details.