Moneywise Investment Trust Awards 2012

10 April 2012

For many investment trusts, 2011 was a stressful year. Against the backdrop of the eurozone debt crisis and slowing growth for major emerging sectors, markets delivered a queasy ride for investors, especially through the turbulent summer months; and, overall, there were more investment trust losers than winners.

But what lies ahead for 2012? Given the economic uncertainties that remain in the UK, Europe and globally, it's hardly surprising that the New Year survey of managers from the Association of Investment Companies (AIC) yielded mixed outlooks.

Nonetheless, the AIC reports that more than 70% of managers expect markets to rise over the course of the year, a forecast strengthened by the market rally in January. The strongest performances are forecast from emerging markets and the US.

But while there's no shortage of pundits making predictions about the most attractive sectors to invest in for 2012, it can be difficult to identify the individual trusts that will serve you best over the long term.

The Moneywise Investment Trust Awards aim to point you in the right direction. We have selected the top trusts in eight of the most popular sectors on the basis of the consistency of their performance over one, three and five years. We've also taken into account the expert views of a panel of financial advisers who make active use of investment trusts for their clients. Below are our winners and runners-up in each sector.



This sector is larger than any other investment trust category and includes a wide range of trust styles and approaches.

The winner, Lindsell Train Investment Trust, has shown remarkable consistency of performance over all time periods, hovering in the top five throughout. "This really is a ‘best ideas' portfolio, with typically fewer than 20 holdings from across global equity markets held by managers Nick Train and Michael Lindsell," says Gavin Haynes, managing director of Whitechurch Securities.

"Holding the trust also provides investors with a 25% stake in the underlying Lindsell Train fund management group, aligning the interests of the fund closely with those of the managers' business."

Anna Sofat, managing director of Addidi Wealth, is keen on Lindsell Train's long-term view and focus on ‘exceptional' companies capable of growing the real value of their profits and cashflows over very long periods of time. "The trust's performance speaks for itself, with consistently strong results over three and five years, alongside low volatility for a global equity fund," she adds.

The runner-up slot goes to two trusts: Ruffer Investment Trust and Personal Assets Trust. "Both these trusts are run in an absolute return style where they are focusing on not losing clients' money," says Simon Moore, senior analyst at Bestinvest.

Tim Cockerill, head of collectives research at Rowan Dartington, likes Personal Assets' broad asset base, including large-cap equities, bonds and other asset classes. He says: "Asset allocation is not benchmarked, allowing the freedom to invest wherever the best opportunities lie and to be defensive whenever required."

For Haynes, Ruffer's successful combination of protecting wealth in tough times and exploiting out-of-favour recovery opportunities makes it a good core holding.



With an attractive income bias, this sector has been one of the most popular over the past year. Investor demand has meant many trusts in this sector trade at a premium – the average discount, as of 8 March, is just -0.6%, compared with, say, the UK growth sector on an average -11.5% discount.

For a second year running, Finsbury Growth & Income, also managed by Lindsell Train, scoops the top slot, albeit by a narrow margin. It is run as a concentrated portfolio of just 26 stocks, managed with low turnover and a longer-term outlook than most.

"Investors are buying the managers, Michael Lindsell and Nick Train. It's a boutique investment management company but they are very focused on what they do, and they do it well," says Cockerill. "The fund's success depends on their ability to find quality businesses that can deliver consistent long-term growth, which is why it requires a long-term approach from investors."

Sofat also picks this trust. As well as its performance record and consistency, she highlights the fact that the discount is actively managed, keeping share price and net asset value (NAV) more or less on a par.

Runner-up Edinburgh Trust is under the respected hand of Invesco Perpetual's Neil Woodford. "It's a focused portfolio of his best ideas, with the top 10 stocks accounting for more than 60% of the fund's total value," says Moore. The fund turned out a positive performance in 2011's tough climate and has outperformed the FTSE All-Share over one, three and five years. Haynes sees it as "an excellent way to gain exposure to blue chip, defensive equity income stocks".



Invesco Perpetual's UK team, headed by Mark Barnett, runs both the winner and the runner-up in this sector. However, the first-placed trust, Keystone, is well ahead of other contenders, with all the judges placing it top of the shortlist.

Sofat describes the Keystone Trust as "possibly one for the less aggressive investor", with "low volatility, a consistent discount to NAV, decent returns, reasonable charges and solid manager tenure".

Haynes agrees: "Barnett aims to provide absolute returns with low volatility and the portfolio provides good core exposure to defensive blue chip companies." That relatively defensive approach helped it produce positive returns in 2011, when the average UK growth trust lost 12%.

Second-placed, Invesco Perpetual Select UK Equity, like Keystone, is a defensively positioned trust with the stamp of the Invesco Perpetual team on it. As Cockerill observes: "The core of both funds is based in the team's long-term view of the UK economy, which has been bearish for a long time."

Sofat points out that Invesco Perpetual Select UK Equity has produced higher three and five-year returns than Keystone, but at the cost of higher volatility; it's also slightly more expensive. However, she adds: "We like the consistent discount to NAV and its decent yield, paid every six months."



Small companies have been a core holding for growth investors over the past decade but they struggled in 2011, as a result of the combination of the UK's recent sluggish economy and investors' general risk-aversion. Nonetheless, our panel gave a firm thumbs up to

Standard Life UK Smaller Companies, our winner in this category for the sixth year running.

Despite a middling performance that saw the trust's value fall by 13% over 2011, manager Harry Nimmo is widely regarded as outstanding in his field. "He has produced solid three and five-year performance with below-average volatility," says Sofat. As Haynes explains: "Nimmo employs a disciplined investment approach, determined by using the group's in-house quantitative approach with a fundamental research overlay."

He regards the trust as "an excellent choice" for anyone looking for a purely UK-focused smaller companies investment. Moore agrees: "Nimmo's open-ended fund is now closed to new investors, so this is the best way to access this excellent manager." An added bonus is the fact that although it often trades at around NAV, it's currently on a 9% discount, so looks good value.

As an alternative, BlackRock Smaller Companies is the favoured choice for the second year running. "BlackRock has a very experienced and well resourced UK smaller companies team; they also manage the Throgmorton Trust," says Cockerill. "They do perhaps take more risk than some in the sector, and of those shortlisted they have the highest volatility scores, but this is reflected in the fact that they are able to add a lot of value."



The US was the only major economy in the world to perform better in the second half of 2011 than in the first half, and it's certainly an area that has been attracting investor interest over recent months. However, there is only a handful of general North American trusts available. The judges were divided but, by a narrow margin, first place goes for a third year to the JPMorgan American Trust, run by Garrett Fish.

"Fish manages a portfolio that provides highly diversified exposure to large, mid-cap and small US stocks, and has achieved the difficult task of outperforming the efficient S&P 500 benchmark over both the long and the short term," says Haynes. "For mainstream US exposure, I believe this is a very good choice."

Second place goes jointly to two very different trusts. The cheap Edinburgh US Tracker makes a good alternative to JPMorgan's offering, says Anna Sofat: "Performance over three and five years is broadly similar but Edinburgh has a highly competitive total expense ratio of 0.68% in its favour."

Edinburgh's tracker ties with a rather unusual specialist trust, Middlefield Canadian Income. It has done very well – returning more than 300% over the three years to the end of 2011 – by investing in income-generating Canadian corporations.

Cockerill warns that the tax status on the underlying corporations has changed, so performance may not be so outstanding looking ahead, but he recommends Middlefield on the grounds of "providing investors with an alternative income option".



There are mixed feelings about the wisdom of investing in Europe at present, but the judges all came to the same conclusion: anyone prepared to ride out the likely short-term volatility in order to exploit a potential recovery in European equities would do well with Jupiter European Opportunities, our winner in this sector for a second year running.

This is an aggressively run trust with a concentrated portfolio – the top 10 holdings make up almost 70% of the trust – and quite a bit of gearing to enhance returns. "Its focus is on the ability of businesses to grow, taking into account the macroeconomic environment – an important factor in the trust's success," explains Cockerill.

That aggressive approach has certainly paid off for longer-term investors, according to Haynes: "Manager Alex Darwall has beaten all other European trusts, as well as the benchmark, over three and five years." However, performance has been less outstanding over the past year, and Sofat is slightly nervous about the relatively high gearing.

There was almost unanimous consensus, too, on the runner-up, Henderson Euro Trust, which Sofat recommends as "something a bit more conservative". Manager Tim Stevenson has been at the helm for 16 years and "is only just behind Jupiter's Darwell in his average monthly outperformance score", according to Moore.

"Performance has been solid in recent years and the trust held up well in a difficult 2011," says Haynes.



Long-term prospects remain attractive but 2011 was a tough year for the Asia Pacific region, with the average trust in this sector down by about 15%. Only the winner, Aberdeen Asian Income, managed to turn in a positive total return during the 12-month period, reflecting the importance of dividend payments in a difficult market.

"Asian income stocks have been performing well and this trust, which is trading at a premium, has been performing well, too," says Cockerill. He highlights its conservative management, focusing on high-quality businesses with sustainable earnings.

Aberdeen is one of the most experienced management groups operating in Asia, with a highly regarded manager in the shape of Hugh Young and "a well-resourced Asian team", adds Haynes. "The trust has produced consistent long-term returns of more than 80% over five years," he says.

Schroder Asia Pacific, in second place, aims for capital growth from a diverse portfolio of shares in companies from developed Asian economies such as Hong Kong, as well as emerging markets in the region.

"We like the broad range of holdings and consistent outperformance of the benchmark index over one, three and five years, and since launch," says Sofat. She adds that the trust has "reasonable volatility for Asia Pacific - close to the IMA sector average for UK equities".

Cockerill is particularly keen on the strong emphasis on fundamental analysis that underpins the selection process in Schroder Asia Pacific: "It's critical when investing in this region to avoid poor stocks," he says.



Emerging markets have also had a difficult year. The sector was down by 17% over 2012, according to AIC data, underlining the fact that these exciting new markets are still a relatively risky option and that investing in them has to be a long-term decision.

Although the relatively small size of the sector means there is a limited number of trusts to pick from, the judges were unanimous in their choice of winner. Top slot for the third year running goes to Templeton Emerging Markets, run since 1989 by the ‘legendary' Dr Mark Mobius and now worth more than £2 billion.

For Cockerill, Templeton's emerging market trust is "the largest, the best-known and still the best". Its strength lies in its extensive resources and local knowledge, which he believes "provides an edge that others don't seem able to match".

But Dr Mark Mobius is very much the star of the show. "He continues to impress us with his market insight and individual stock knowledge. At Bestinvest we give him four stars for consistency of outperformance," says Moore.

Second place, also by unanimous vote, remains with last year's runner-up JPMorgan Emerging Markets – a well-resourced fund managed by a 40-strong team and headed by Austin Forey. Haynes sees it as "an excellent way to get well diversified, well-managed exposure to emerging markets".

Importantly, says Sofat, both trusts show consistency in their discounts to NAV. That suggests share prices are well supported by steady demand from investors, and shareholders are less likely to get any nasty surprises with sudden swings in share price.



For the third year running, JPMorgan scoops the award for management group of the year. As Cockerill emphasises, picking an overall winner is always difficult because of the many different shapes and sizes of investment groups.

However, he says, JPMorgan shapes up in terms of the range of trusts managed (amounting to 24 in total) the resources available to managers and the overall performance of its trusts. The JPMorgan American Trust also topped the poll for the North American sector.

"As a whole, I think JPMorgan is a bedrock of the investment trust world, offering investors an excellent choice, from UK mid cap, mainstream Europe and America, to Brazil, Russia and China," he says. "But perhaps most importantly, I believe investors can trust it, and that performance won't let them down."

Haynes seconds the choice, noting the group's large number of quality investment trusts. JPMorgan "provides investors with leading trusts in both mainstream and esoteric areas", he says. It's also worth mentioning Lindsell Train, which is a very different kind of manager operating on a much smaller scale.

It manages two of this year's winning trusts: Lindsell Train Investment Trust and Finsbury Growth & Income. Sofat applauds the group's "long-term consistency, volatility management, good performance and the fact that it makes clients' interests the same as its own".

Add new comment