Three bad ideas for your pension

Many of you will be pretty confused about what the new rules will mean for your pension fund. That's hardly surprising, since the details are not finalised yet. What we do know, however, is that most people over age 55 will have the opportunity to make new decisions about how, when or whether to take money from their fund.

Given all the uncertainties at the moment, there might be a temptation to make quick decisions but I would like to offer some words of caution to think very carefully before making any moves.

In particular, there is an interim regime in place now, which still restricts withdrawals, while the full freedoms won't come in until April 2015. As we don't know how all the details of the new regime will work, it could well be worth waiting for the government announcements on this in the coming months.

I'd like to suggest three things you might be tempted to do that could turn out to be a bad idea.

Find the best pension funds available on your selected pension platform

Withdrawing all the cash

The first is taking money out as cash straight away, if you don't really need to. After next April, the rules will change, but for now, if your total pension savings are worth under £30,000 or if you have three funds each valued under £10,000, the interim rules introduced following the Budget allow you to take all the money as cash. Should you be in a rush to cash your pension in?

Before you do, it is worth considering the significant tax benefits of pensions relative to money saved in other ways. If you take the money and run, you lose the tax benefits of being in a pension fund. Investment returns in your pension fund are tax free, but taking any more than the tax free lump sum means paying tax your marginal rate on the rest. If you are still working, you might lose 40% or 45% in tax, whereas if you take money out later, and in smaller amounts over time, you could pay far less tax in future.

Another potential tax advantage of not cashing the pension in is that if you have not taken any money out of your fund and you die before age 75 those assets can pass on tax-free. However, if you take even a small amount out of your fund, the balance will be taxed at 55%. The government is planning to change these tax rules so it might be worth waiting to see what the new tax structure will be.

Purchasing a lifetime annuity

Another course of action that might not be such a good idea is buying a lifetime annuity straight away. Of course annuities offer a secure income, but given the prospect of new freedoms, it is likely that providers will be developing new kinds of product that could be more suitable for you in future.

If you buy a standard annuity now, you will not be able to change it as they are irreversible. If better products come along, if rates rise, if your health changes, you will never be able to take advantage of better future deals. It will be worth taking financial advice before committing to a lifelong irreversible decision.

Find the best annuity rate for your circumstances

Failing to plan ahead

The third course of action that you may well regret later is failing to make a proper financial plan, if you haven't already done so. The new freedoms offer far more opportunities to plan your future income carefully.

Under the old regime, your pension choices were strictly limited - you could only cash in two pension funds worth under £2,000 each, or total pension savings worth under £18,000. In all other cases, taking any money out of a pension fund, meant you had to either buy an annuity, or income drawdown product.

After April 2015, you will have the chance to plan to withdraw as much or as little as you wish and to integrate your pension savings with your other sources of income and also plan to take out pension assets in the most tax-efficient way. So I would strongly suggest that you don't decide what to do with your pension savings without sitting down and making your own financial plan. Assess your future income, how much money you will want or need to spend, how much earned income you might have coming in and then how your pension fund or other assets can be used to fill the gap.

Until we have the full details of the new rules, think very carefully before making any hasty or irreversible decisions. These are likely to be really exciting times for pensions, with lots of new products being developed offering far more options to those who wait.

Jargon buster: the 'Portfolio Turnover Rate' (PTR)

Your pension fund charges may include what is called the 'Portfolio Turnover Rate' - what does this mean? It is a measure of how often the assets in your fund are bought and sold by the managers over the past year. The higher the PTR, the more trading transactions your fund manager has done during the year and the more he has changed the investments.

The more trading the fund does, the higher the costs you pay will be, because each transaction will incur a dealing charge. The calculation usually takes either the net total amount of new securities bought - or sold - divided by the total net asset value of the fund.

This article was written for our sister website Money Observer

More about

Your Comments

'After April 2015, you will have the chance to plan to withdraw as much or as little as you wish'
I wish financial organisations and journalists would stop saying this and make it clear that at present these rules do not apply to SIPPs. Many of us have our pension savings in SIPPs and until the other week I was completely unaware that I would not have this flexibility with regard to my SIPP as nobody has publicised the fact. I would like an article to be written exploring and explaining this; I think it is very unfair that the same rules do not apply to SIPPs.