Regulator names savings providers that pay 0% interest

zero money

Savings providers offering the lowest interest rates to savers in easy-access cash and individual savings accounts (Isas) have been named by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). 

This is the regulator’s ‘sunlight remedy’, which aims to embarrass providers into offering better interest rates for closed account customers, by shining a light on firms’ strategies towards their long-standing customers. The data is based on rates as at April 2016 and shows that some accounts pay 0% interest. 

Providers that should be most embarrassed include the Post Office, which the FCA says pays absolutely nothing to both open and closed account holders.

A Post Office spokesperson said: “All our savings accounts are offered with an interest rate of at least 0.1%. The FCA report gives the impression that we have had a 0.0% rate, but it is important to emphasise that this is not the case. This relates to some of our products that require a minimum £500 deposit and where we make clear to customers that they will not be eligible for interest if the amount in the account falls below £500.

“More broadly, our rates are open and transparent in our literature, we are very clear with customers about what their rate is and will be, and we regularly feature in best buy tables, confirming our competitive position. While some of our customers are on a rate of 0.1%, they will have benefited from a guaranteed bonus for at least 12 months. We write to all customers about a month before the end of the bonus rate to let them know what their rate will be changing to and offer a full range of savings products so that customers can take out the product that best suits their needs.” 

Meanwhile, M&S Bank, which pays 1.3% to open easy-access cash Isas that can be managed in branch but just 0.05% to similar accounts that are closed.

What should savers do?

Savers should check any long-standing accounts as a priority to make sure that they are getting the best rate. See our top cash savings and top cash Isa guides for weekly updated best buys.   

Christopher Woolard, director of strategy and competition at the FCA, says: “We said that one of our priorities this year will be focused on the treatment of long-standing customers. Our new rules, coming into force at the end of the year, will help consumers get the facts they need to make an informed decision about what to do with their savings.

“In a well-functioning market, providers should be competing to offer the best possible deal to consumers. Our sunlight remedy data shows that some consumers could be better off by opening a different account.”

In response to the findings, analysts at Hargreaves Lansdown have put together a five-point action plan for savers:

1. Pay down debt
The cost of borrowing is almost certainly higher than the returns from your cash savings.

2. Shop around
Some closed accounts pay no interest and often significantly lower interest rates than open accounts. Shopping around and then switching should improve your returns, in some cases more than 10 fold.

80% of people with easy-access accounts haven’t switched over a five-year period, according to the FCA, and yet this is often the best way to improve the returns on your cash. Cash Isa accounts can be switched to a new provider in 15 days or less.

3. Use your tax breaks
Fully utilise your tax free personal allowances and the new personal savings allowance of £1,000. Combine these and a basic rate taxpaying couple can receive £24,000 in income and interest this tax year, completely tax-free.

4. Use Isa allowances
An individual savings account (Isa) shelters interest from the taxman and this can improve your overall returns. Even with the new personal savings allowance, using your Isa £15,240 allowance is good tax saving discipline.

Certain types of Isa have other benefits: the Help to Buy Isa provides a 25% government bonus to first-time buyers when they buy a property. From April 2017, the Lifetime Isa will also provide a 25% bonus to savers under 40 either to help first-time buyers onto the property ladder or for longer term retirement savings.

5. Consider switching some long-term savings from cash to the stock market
It’s important to hold some cash, but not too much. While income from a £10,000 cash deposit has fallen by 86% since 1996, dividend income from a popular equity income fund has remained steady. However ,when you factor in the growth in the capital value which in turn grows the dividends, the income has increased by 268% (and the capital increased to £39,930). 

Income over 20 years from £10,000 starting capital

Year Income from equities with capital growth 90 Day Notice
    Cash Account
1996 £346.18 £430.76
1997 £375.15 £484.23
1998 £394.62 £547.05
1999 £543.45 £370.18
2000 £555.17 £402.26
2001 £607.32 £363.01
2002 £605.31 £268.92
2003 £716.21 £247.26
2004 £474.94 £315.02
2005 £668.91 £348.99
2006 £809.75 £343.62
2007 £1,018.60 £428.04
2008 £1,045.60 £398.25
2009 £1,087.87 £116.48
2010 £1,061.18 £105.20
2011 £1,133.98 £117.51
2012 £1,165.97 £125.50
2013 £1,186.50 £90.44
2014 £1,256.95 £69.58
2015 £1,274.45 £60.36
Total income taken £16,328 £5,632
Capital remaining £39,930 £10,000

Source: Lipper, Invesco Perpetual High Income fund vs Moneyfacts 90 Days Notice Cash Account