Can you still make money from day trading?

Day trading is one of the riskiest ways of putting money into assets such as shares, commodities and foreign currency. But the flipside is that the potential returns can be significantly higher than more traditional forms of investing.

Strictly speaking, day trading means taking a position on an asset and then closing it out on the same day, with the aim of making a quick profit. The practice has been around for several decades – day trading began in the UK in 1974 when a group of bankers led by Stuart Wheeler set up IG Index to allow investors to speculate on the price of gold.

But the concept really took off towards the end of the Nineties thanks largely to the spread of the internet, which made it far easier to get information and to execute trades quickly, and the dotcom bubble, which ran from around 1997 to the spring of 2000. During that period, it wasn't just easier to trade - soaring share prices meant that day trading also appeared to be extremely lucrative.

But even in the years before the tech bubble burst, short-term trading was far from a one-way bet: as well as anecdotal evidence of huge instant gains made by private investors, there were numerous stories of massive losses suffered by people who could not afford them.

In the summer of 1999, several months before the crash, the North American Securities Administrators Association (NASAA), a US investor protection organisation, published a report warning of the dangers of day trading. Its research found that 70% of private traders would "almost certainly lose everything they invest". And only 11.5% of the day-trading accounts studied by the NASAA showed "the ability to conduct profitable short-term trading".

In the immediate aftermath of the dotcom bust in March 2000, the popularity of day trading waned on both sides of the Atlantic. But today, this approach to investment is in rude health, with participants either buying and selling shares directly through a wide range of online brokers or using the growing number of spread- betting platforms to leverage their investments.

Jonathan Cumberlidge, head of sales at trading platform CityIndex,says: "Theappeal of trading continues to grow as people are becoming increasingly financially savvy and self-directed. It is no longer exclusively the domain of financial professionals and we have customers from all walks of life.

"As we have been experiencing long-term low interest rates, many retail investors are unhappy with the returns they make from regular savings products, and trading offers an accessible way to try to make a larger return on investment."

There are now more websites and blogs analysing companies and stockmarkets than ever before: private investors certainly have no shortage of information. And the growth of mobile internet and investment apps means that day traders no longer need to sit at a desk for hours on end, monitoring price movements.

Getting started

So how do you take your first steps in day trading? Patrick Connolly at independent financial adviser Chase de Vere says: "Anyone can engage in day trading, in much the same way as anybody can open an online account with a bookmaker and bet on the horses.

"But the starting point needs to be determining what you want to achieve: are you looking at day trading as a new career where you'll be relying on profits to pay for your day-to-day living costs? Or is it just a hobby where you'll be 'playing' with money that you can afford to lose?"

Leslie adds: "The best way to get first-hand experience of trading is to open a demo trading account with your broker; it's no different to real trading, except you are using it as a practice account, rather than using your money.

"The commitment for day trading will depend on how regularly you trade and the strategies and instruments you want to adopt. It is important for anyone interested in trading to develop a strong fundamental understanding of how the financial markets work and the most important characteristics of various trading strategies, asset classes and instruments on offer. Some retail investors trade as a hobby, some do it part time, and for others it is a full-time profession."

Malcolm Stacey, a financial journalist and author of Share Attack, a new book on getting started in trading, says that it is vital that day traders are ready to close out their positions at a moment's notice. "You need to keep your screen open all the time, with your sell button poised, and you should pay for an online real-time share-value service. Most brokers offer a free share movement service, but they are 15 minutes delayed. You actually need real time to be safe."

Real-time share prices are available from the likes of and ADVFN – both sites offer a basic free service, with the option to upgrade to get alerts on specific stocks or access to bulletin boards used by other traders.

Your trading options

You also need to decide whether to trade directly in shares or use a spread-betting platform.

Spread betting allows you to speculate on the movement of shares, stockmarket indices or exchange rates, say, over a fixed period. For example, you might expect the FTSE 100 to rise on a particular day, so you could buy a stake of £5 per point. If the index rises by
50 points above the 'buy' price, you would make £250; equally, if it finished 50 points below, you would lose £250.

With spread betting, you don't own the underlying asset and your position is leveraged – which means gains or losses can be far greater than any initial stake or deposit. (With spread bets, you can also profit from falls in value.)

By day trading directly in shares through a broker, your potential losses are limited to the value of your holdings.

Your tax position

There are some tax advantages to spread betting, Stacey says. "Ordinary day trading – buying and selling shares via an online broker – means you have to pay stamp duty and spread on the purchases. You may also have to make detailed records for capital gains purposes.

"If you spread bet, you avoid stamp duty and capital gains tax, though you still have a spread to pay. Most day traders now would do it through spread betting."

Some brokers will allow you to trade shares within a stocks and shares Isa, which means you can invest up to £15,240 a year without any subsequent gains being subject to capital gains tax. Any dividends you receive will be recorded by your broker – higher- and top-rate taxpayers will need to declare them unless the shares are held in an Isa.

Plan your trading strategy

It is also worth thinking about what your approach to trading is going to be. "The best strategy is to use self-discipline," says Stacey. "Set a target to which you expect the share to rise and sell at that point. Don't wait, hoping for more.

"Pick shares that are already rising: the trend is your friend. If a share starts the day on the up it will usually continue to shine. But sell at the day's end at the latest – a day trade can easily become a long-term trade if it loses money on the first day, because you are loath to sell a loser. But sell it anyway, because the day after a big leap for a share often sees the stock fall back to where it was – or worse."

Some traders use technical analysis to help them make buying and selling decisions – for example, they may believe that a particular share has a short-term "price ceiling", that is, a level above which it is unlikely to rise in the near future, for example £1 or £5.

This may lead them to sell as the price approaches the ceiling. Some day traders use historical analysis of stockmarkets, slavishly adhere to a bewildering array of predictive charts, or use the words of famous economists as gospel.

Indeed, another method is to trade based on news, either concerning specific companies or the economy in general. However, Connolly warns: "Professional fund managers, backed by huge investment research resources, cannot be relied upon to consistently make the right short-term tactical decisions, so what chance does somebody sitting at home in front of a computer screen really have?"

It is also possible to put 'stop loss orders' on trades or spread bets: this means that if an asset falls to a pre-determined level, your position is automatically closed. But this is not a fail-safe method, Stacey warns: "Sadly, stop-loss systems do not always work. A manual share selling action is best."

Weigh up the risks

Would-be day traders need to consider the risks, Connolly says. "Even when day traders make profits, it could be that buy-and-hold investors would have achieved better returns with much less effort, in part because their dealing costs are likely to be much lower.

"While the prospects of making big gains could be appealing, much like betting on the horses, for most people it makes absolute no sense to invest money they cannot afford to lose."

Robbie Burns, author of the Naked Trader blog and several books on investment strategy, is even more forthright. "Prospects are terrible for new day traders," he says. "At least 95% will lose their money over time. Day traders are battling with robot computers, clever algorithms and companies that have spent millions trading in mega amounts.

"How any would-be day trader thinks they can possibly beat the casino is beyond me. There may have been a chance of making some money doing it many years ago. Not now."

Burns says that medium-term investment is likely to be a much more suitable strategy. "This means finding very good companies that pay good dividends, as well as realising that making money takes time," he explains. "One also has to learn discipline: that is, the ability to cut losers quickly and the patience to run winners for a long time."

More about