Three rip-off insurance products to avoid

Do you consider yourself a risk taker?

Your answer may determine your attitude to insurance and whether you think it is an absolute must, sensible or a big con. Insurance is a multibillion pound business - more than 1,000 companies are licensed to offer general insurance in the UK, according to the Association of British Insurers (ABI), selling dozens of different types of policies that offer protection for everything from identity theft to erupting volcanoes.

The ABI estimates that the average household spent £1,068 on insurance in 2009. However, cases of policies not paying out when they should and the £8 billion scandal surrounding the mis-selling of payment protection insurance for loans and credit cards, have led some to wonder whether it isn't all just a huge waste of money.

"The array of insurance products out there reflects the needs of consumers. They are made in response to something - for meeting needs, not creating them - and the range simply reflects that life has become more risky," says Malcolm Tarling, ABI spokesperson.

Pete Harrison, insurance expert at comparison website, says: "There are some essential policies everyone should have: car, buildings if you are a homeowner, travel if you go away and income protection if you have dependants - everything else depends on your lifestyle, attitude to risk and what you can afford."

So, what don't you need? We look at some of the rip-off insurance products to avoid.



As mobile phones have got smarter, they've become more expensive too. And given the high chance of damaging them, losing them or having yours stolen, it's understandable why so many of us are tempted to insure our handsets.

But while it's a good idea to have some cover, it's more cost-effective to insure your phone through home contents insurance than standalone policies, which can cost £180 a year. Just be aware that repeated claims could lead to an increase in your contents insurance premiums.


These usually require a small monthly payment of, say, £5, to cover the breakage of household items such as washing machines and TVs. It is easy to end up paying out more in monthly premiums than the item would cost to replace over time.

For example, a five-year extended warranty on a washing machine with a small chance of needing repair in the first five years could cost £170, when the initial price of the appliance was only £260.


Sold alongside credit cards, card protection policies cost around £30 a year and identity theft insurance, about £70. But these policies usually offer customers little more protection than you already get free from providers under the Banking Code and Consumer Credit Act.

For example, Experian offers identity protection insurance for £6.99 a month, but all you get is a credit report monitoring and assistance if your identity is stolen - all of which you can get free.

Find the best credit card with Moneywise Best Buys



Do not always accept your current insurer's renewal and beware auto-renewals onto higher premiums. It is easy to miss reminders so keep a diary note of renewal dates and shop around a couple oof weeks beforehand. Comparison websites such as, and are a good starting place.


Check existing policies to ensure you are not already covered. For example, check whether your mobile phone is covered on your contents insurance before coughing up for another policy. Also check
whether your employer provides life or medical cover.


Make sure the things you would be likely to claim for are worth more than the excess. And make sure you can afford to pay the excess.


Most insurance premiums are cheaper if you pay the full amount in one go rather than paying in monthly installments.

Your Comments

 "These usually require a small monthly payment of, say, £5, to cover the breakage of household items such as washing machines and TVs. It is easy to end up paying out more in monthly premiums than the item would cost to replace over time."
One important thing you miss from here anyway is that even if the original warranty goes on a product the courts rule a reasonable life of a product, and if the product fails within it's reasonable life due to any initial fault anyway you are covered, which is exactly what the extended warranties are selling you.
One of the best examples of this is the Microsoft Xbox Red Ring of Death fault.  As this was a known fault when the Xbox was made Microsoft were forced to extend the warranty against this defect for up to 3 years which is the reasonable life of the Xbox regardless of whether the existing warranty was invalid in anyway.
Many retailers wont tell you about this reasonable lifetime of a product and try and fob you off telling you it's out of warranty, but usually if you mention to them that you'll be going to trading standards and see what they say, many will be more than happy to sort things out as it's not worth it 'cos they know then that they can't just get away with fobbing you off.  
Quite a lot of major appliances even with a 12-month warranty are actually covered with this for up to 3 years - TV's, washing machines, dishwashers, microwaves, etc.