Moneywise Magazine: 3 issues for £1 subscription offer
|  Login  |  Register  |  Contact us  |  Help  |  Subscribe  

Paying off mortgage v saving

Tue, 25/12/2007 - 12:22

I have an Alliance and Leicester Fixed Rate Mortgage (4.94%) that I took out in 2006 for £130,000 that runs out in August 08 (I will have 18 years left). I am allowed only one overpayment every January and can pay upto 10 per cent off. I have £7500 in a Halifax ISA (5.75%) which I intended to withdraw to make an overpayment. The problem - I will lose 180 days worth of ISA interest if I withdraw the money early to make the overpayment. Is it worth me losing the interest to make the overpayment? Advice please?

Tue, 01/01/2008 - 17:57

This looks like a bad idea - but the question is what happens to the rate at the expiry of your fixed rate? It is quite possible that at that point (Aug 08) you are at liberty to pay off any sum and by waiting till then you do not need to sacrifice your ISA interest (nor your ISA allowance which you should for prudence's sake use to hold a couple or three months salary for emergencies.

You should start looking at alternative mortgage deals now so you appreciate the range and variety available by the time the crunch comes - don't accept the standard variable rate if you can avoid it as there are much better deals around. I just got a lifetime tracker that is currently at 5.79% so there's little point foregoing the ready cash in a couple of cash ISAs to knock any off that. I was able to transfer with no costs or fees.

Wed, 02/01/2008 - 11:34

Check out our new mortgage and savings calculators - these can help you work out how much you stand to lose by cashing in your ISA and balance this up against the savings to be made by paying a lump sum off your mortgage.

Rachel Lacey is the editor of Moneywise

Mon, 07/01/2008 - 10:18

Normally I would tell people to reduce any debt they have if possible, however in your case your ISA is tax-free, so is making more money than your mortgage is costing you. This means that you are making a net profit, and should not lose the ISA to pay the mortgage off. Only if the mortgage starts costing you more than you are making on the ISA should you shift the money over, or if the government changes the tax rules and your net profit from the ISA does not beat the cost of your other borrowing. Make sure you prepare your remortgage in good time for August (allow 8 weeks for the application) and that the total cost of the fee plus the interest over the next few years works out lower than the annual total income from the ISA.

Katie Tucker is a product specialist at John Charcol and a Moneywise Ask The Professionals columnist

Mon, 07/01/2008 - 22:38

Hi - having just read this month's mag, I'm considering my options regarding a cash ISA.
We (my wife and I) currently have an offset mortgage with a rate of 6.7%. At the moment we are lucky enough to pay no interest due to the savings deposited, but do repay the capital each month. We are about to build a home extension that will reduce these savings by around £40,000, therefore meaning we will pay interest on this figure.
We plan to repay the capital over about 10 years and can budget £300 per month to do so. My questions are as follows.
1. Is it better to leave the £300 in our mortgage/savings account each month therefore offsetting and reducing the outstanding balance, or...
2. Put this £300 in a cash ISA over the next 10 years or so (I can also afford to put this year's limit of £3000 into a cash ISA - but would lose the benefit of this offsetting the mortgage if I did so) or...
3. Leave the £300 in the bank each month and transfer to a cash ISA as a lump sum at the end of each tax year.
I'm afraid I don't know enough about how interest is calculated to make the decision with any real certainty. Any help/advice would be gratefully received.
Thankyou

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <b> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <br> <p> <h3> <hr> <div>
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.

More information about formatting options

Moneywise

News, articles, advice and guides from everyday money issues to how to grow your money. Covering all aspects of personal finance, Moneywise offers independent news and views, forums and blogs, as well as unique compare and buy comparison tools.

Moneywise distributes services supplied by Interactive Investor. Interactive Investor Trading Limited, trading as "Interactive Investor", is authorised and regulated by the Financial Services Authority. Copyright © 2008 Moneywise. Terms & Conditions   About   Contact us   Subscriptions