Travel plans ruined by volcanic ash?

image
Johanna Gornitzki
Fri, 16/04/2010 - 15:31

Have you been affected by the volcanic eruption in Iceland? Will your insurance pay out?

Do you think travel insurers are ripping people off by labelling these kind of events as "Acts of God"? Share your views below...

Guest (not verified):

I have an Endsleigh policy. In the policy there is no mention of exceptions for Natural Disasters. However Endsleigh have now put on their website that Natural Disasters are not included in their policies and won't pay out for such an event.

Avril Foster (not verified):

Be careful I have just heard that someone who had been stuck in Spain and had used their credit card to buy train and ferry tickets etc so they could get back to this country had a message from their bank sent to them stating them bank - Lloyds could help them. When they phoned the bank on their Premium rate no. they said they couldn't help them.

Guest (not verified):

As always the insurance in this country (UK) is going to avoid paying out any money on its holiday insurance policies that were bought in the expectation that they would cover unexpected events . "Acts of God" is the easiest way for them to do it but what if the insured doesnt believe in God or the existence of a Universal get out clause. As always they employ people working hard at defining reasons which remove their liability.
The policies always come with a huge amount of small print but if they listed the items that they dont intend to pay for then there wouldnt be paper enough to print them on and no one in their right mind would buy Insurance..
Insurance companies in the UK are a poor excuse for monetary theft and second only to the large banking institutions

MartinMc (not verified):

It would be great if you could collate and list all those policies which include "natural disasters" or other "acts of God/ force majoer" at the end of this so we could all make our own informed choices in future as it looks like Iceland will happen again

When is a disaster 'natural', or Act of God???

Are the planes not flying because of an eruption and the ensuing ash..., or because someone at N.A.T.S. have decided it's too dangerous, rightly or wrongly.

In more simple terms; what about flooding?

If your house floods because it rains heavily and a river floods.., thats a natural disaster. But what if the Rivers Authority have installed a weir and deliberately flood your area because it's cheaper than allowing another area to flood. This happens all the time with the Thames, to save London. Man has intervened, and it's no longer in the hands of God or nature!

The insurers save a fortune downstream, but refuse to compensate those upstream! (It's not a problem I have, I have just never understood the rationale)

 

KrisnotChris (not verified):

It's a sign of the times, I s'pose.

In an idealistic world (one that I drift into now and again), I'm sure we'd all like to see the insurers reach into their fairly substantial pockets to recompense the unfortunate thousands affected by the volcano.

Alas, it's all about balance sheets and shareholder returns, so I can't see many (if any) insurers paying out unless they really have to.

After all, does it say in the small print that a disaster such as this means we can get our money back?

Guest (not verified):

Could it not be agrued that it was not the 'act of God' which stopped the planes flying it was a person/organisation telling them not to fly? If a river floods your house it does so directly however when the volcano erupts it has not taken out all planes, man has made the decision. Would this be covered do you think? You would have arguably got on a plane if there had been one, which there were, albeit grounded by man not God. Whether for our safety or not.

Have just phoned our insurance company (Insurefor.com)and been told that it will not cover "natural disasters" although it would pay out for adverse weather conditions!!  Nowhere in the policy does it exclude natural disasters, therefore surely they should be covered?

Having purchased an annual policy I feel that I have been royally ripped off!

Will send in a claim, wait for them to decline it and then appeal to the Financial Ombudsman I guess - bet Christmas comes first, not my refund!

Webster (not verified):

ENDSLEIGH policy.
We have the same policy and basically they have told us to go away, surely this could come under "adverse weather conditions". I feel that ENDSLEIGH are changing the rules as they go on. AXA is their underwriters. Come on AXA look and take a leaf out of DIRECT TRAVEL INSURANCE who are paying out under the "adverse weather conditions". NAME AND SHAME YOU!!!!!

Guest (not verified):

Not sure how Insure and Go managed to win the Moneywise most trusted travel insurance award. I doubt they would win this again bearing in mind the approach they have taken in relation to not paying out for the volcanic ash problem.

Guest (not verified):

My policy is with Europ Assistance, bought through Flexicover Direct - they too are not paying out as it was a natural disaster. Everyone else I know seems to be able to claim so I feel ripped off too. I wish there was a name and shame list somewhere!

Linda Nelson (not verified):

My husband and I and another couple were stranded in the US due to the icelandic eruption on 14 April.
This is when we found that the supposed 24 hrs. helpline with our insurer, SAGA, was only for medical emergencies. The no. for claims is an 0845 no. only manned (or as we found not manned, 65 mins. on hold) during office hrs. Mon-Fri and Sat. morning. We emailed them and received a reply to say that we were all covered and to keep receipts of hotels and extra travel. On our return we tried to make a claim and when we phoned for claim forms, I was told that we were not covered because we were not checked in (I have our boarding passes as proof). My friend was told that she could not have been delayed for the stated reason as planes were not grounded until the 15th and she could not make a claim. We were in the US and it was still 14 April there.
Linda